Determining Tax on Roth IRA Distributions in 5 Easy Steps
Determining Tax on Roth IRA Distributions in 5 Easy Steps
October 8, 2024
October 8, 2024

What are the ordering rules? Roth IRA distributions can consist of contributions, converted funds and

earnings – or any combination of the three. To determine what your distribution is, you must use “ordering

rules” which dictate the order in which these categories of Roth IRA money must be withdrawn. All Roth

IRAs are considered one Roth IRA for distribution purposes. A Roth IRA distribution will consist first of

any Roth IRA contributions. If there are no contributions or those amounts are completely exhausted, the

next funds out are converted funds. Once all converted funds have been exhausted, the remainder of the

distributions will consist of earnings.


1. Are you withdrawing a contribution? Roth IRA contributions are the annual amounts that you

contribute to a Roth IRA account. A distribution of Roth IRA contributions will always be both tax

and penalty free.


2. Are you withdrawing converted amounts before age 59 ½? Converted funds are never subject

to income tax. However, they will be subject to the 10% penalty for early distributions (unless

an exception applies) if you are under 59 ½ and they have been in a Roth IRA for less than five

years. Each conversion starts its own 10% penalty 5-year clock, and the converted amounts are

withdrawn on a first-in, first-out basis.


3. Are you withdrawing converted amounts after 5 years or age 59 ½? A distribution of

converted funds after 5 years or after age 59 ½ will be entirely income tax and penalty free.


4. Are you withdrawing earnings before age 59 ½? Earnings withdrawn prior to age 59 ½ are

generally subject to income tax regardless of how long they’ve been in a Roth IRA account.

Earnings withdrawn prior to age 59 ½ are also generally subject to the 10% penalty for early

distributions unless an exception applies.


5. Are you withdrawing earnings after age 59 ½ and 5 years? Earnings withdrawn after age 59

½ are never subject to the 10% penalty. They may, however, be subject to income tax. If you have

held any Roth IRA for more than 5 years, your earnings are tax free. If not, they are taxable at

ordinary rates.

By Walter Storholt June 19, 2025
Trusts are often touted as smart estate planning tools, but could they actually reduce taxes for your heirs? In this listener mailbag episode, Frank responds to a question from Roger, who asks whether setting up a trust could help his children save on taxes when inheriting investment accounts.
June 12, 2025
If you've recently been pre-approved for a mortgage, you might be surprised by how much house you technically can buy. But qualifying for a certain loan amount doesn’t always mean it aligns with your financial goals. In today’s episode, Frank answers a listener’s question about whether it might make sense to buy at the top of your budget, or to consider a more measured approach.
By Walter Storholt June 5, 2025
If you’ve switched jobs in the past few years, chances are you’ve got an old 401k sitting somewhere, collecting dust and possibly fees. Today, Frank answers a listener’s question about what to do with old 401ks, when a rollover might make sense, and how to avoid common pitfalls when making the switch.
May 29, 2025
When do multiple beneficiaries exist? Multiple beneficiaries exist when an individual names more than one beneficiary for their IRA. When should you name more than one beneficiary? When you want your IRA assets to go to more than one person or entity without having to incur additional fees or paperwork by maintaining separate accounts for each beneficiary.
May 29, 2025
If I miss the 60-day deadline for completing an IRA rollover, is there any way to save the rollover amount from tax? Failing to complete a 60-day rollover on time can cause the rollover amount to be taxed as income and perhaps subject to a 10% early withdrawal penalty. However, the deadline may have been missed due to reasons that are not the taxpayer’s fault. Fortunately, for such cases, the IRS has created an easy, low-cost way to fix late rollover errors. Revenue Procedure 2016-47 enables individuals to self-certify that they are eligible for a waiver of the 60-day deadline and complete a late rollover
By Walter Storholt May 29, 2025
Plenty of people have concerns about stock market volatility, a potential recession on the horizon, and worries for the economy amidst recent news. What if you’ve had 2025 marked on the calendar for a while as the year you plan to retire? Is this a bad time to do it?
May 22, 2025
Market volatility has a way of shaking confidence. It's easy to feel uncertain, but reacting without a plan could do more harm than the drop itself. In this special mailbag episode, Frank tackles timely listener questions about navigating today’s uncertain market.
May 15, 2025
When the market is volatile, it's easy to feel like you're the only one who's ever felt this anxious. But some of the greatest investors in history have lived through chaos, and they left behind wisdom that still applies today. In this episode, Frank turns to voices like Warren Buffett, Benjamin Graham, and Jack Bogle to remind us how to stay grounded when everything feels uncertain.
May 8, 2025
When markets are shaky, it’s tempting to pull your money out and “wait for things to settle.” But what if that instinct could cost you in lost growth? In this episode, Frank shares compelling statistics on what happens when investors miss the best days in the market, and how a few wrong moves could potentially reduce your long-term returns.
May 1, 2025
What happens when you make too much money to contribute to a Roth IRA? In today’s episode, we open the mailbag to answer a listener’s question about what tax-advantaged opportunities exist when a Roth isn’t on the table.
Show More