Determining Tax on Roth IRA Distributions in 5 Easy Steps
Determining Tax on Roth IRA Distributions in 5 Easy Steps
October 8, 2024
October 8, 2024

What are the ordering rules? Roth IRA distributions can consist of contributions, converted funds and

earnings – or any combination of the three. To determine what your distribution is, you must use “ordering

rules” which dictate the order in which these categories of Roth IRA money must be withdrawn. All Roth

IRAs are considered one Roth IRA for distribution purposes. A Roth IRA distribution will consist first of

any Roth IRA contributions. If there are no contributions or those amounts are completely exhausted, the

next funds out are converted funds. Once all converted funds have been exhausted, the remainder of the

distributions will consist of earnings.


1. Are you withdrawing a contribution? Roth IRA contributions are the annual amounts that you

contribute to a Roth IRA account. A distribution of Roth IRA contributions will always be both tax

and penalty free.


2. Are you withdrawing converted amounts before age 59 ½? Converted funds are never subject

to income tax. However, they will be subject to the 10% penalty for early distributions (unless

an exception applies) if you are under 59 ½ and they have been in a Roth IRA for less than five

years. Each conversion starts its own 10% penalty 5-year clock, and the converted amounts are

withdrawn on a first-in, first-out basis.


3. Are you withdrawing converted amounts after 5 years or age 59 ½? A distribution of

converted funds after 5 years or after age 59 ½ will be entirely income tax and penalty free.


4. Are you withdrawing earnings before age 59 ½? Earnings withdrawn prior to age 59 ½ are

generally subject to income tax regardless of how long they’ve been in a Roth IRA account.

Earnings withdrawn prior to age 59 ½ are also generally subject to the 10% penalty for early

distributions unless an exception applies.


5. Are you withdrawing earnings after age 59 ½ and 5 years? Earnings withdrawn after age 59

½ are never subject to the 10% penalty. They may, however, be subject to income tax. If you have

held any Roth IRA for more than 5 years, your earnings are tax free. If not, they are taxable at

ordinary rates.

May 1, 2025
What happens when you make too much money to contribute to a Roth IRA? In today’s episode, we open the mailbag to answer a listener’s question about what tax-advantaged opportunities exist when a Roth isn’t on the table.
April 24, 2025
Can children have IRAs?
April 24, 2025
How can I avoid making costly mistakes when I inherit an IRA from a person who was not my spouse?
April 24, 2025
Some investors like to do it alone- but is that the wisest path as retirement approaches? In this episode, Frank answers a listener’s question about whether DIY investing makes sense later in life. Sam has managed his own portfolio without an advisor or broker for years. But now he’s wondering if that approach holds up as the financial landscape gets more complicated.
By Walter Storholt April 17, 2025
Are HSAs good tax-advantaged accounts? Can you really accumulate funds over the years and use them tax-free in retirement? This is what listener Beth is wondering. She maxes out her HSA every year without touching it. We’ll discuss whether this strategy could be a smart move or if there are potential pitfalls to consider.
April 10, 2025
Tax season is here and it’s the perfect time to start planning for 2025 and beyond. In this episode, Frank dives into the key tax changes for 2025 that could impact your retirement strategy. From increased 401(k) contribution limits to standard deduction increases, Frank breaks down actionable strategies that could help maximize your tax savings this year and beyond.
By Walter Storholt April 3, 2025
Today’s topic comes from a question from Janice, who was recently laid off at 53 and is considering a career change into real estate. But to make it work, she may need to tap into her IRA to make ends meet. Could this put her long-term financial security at risk?
By Walter Storholt March 27, 2025
April Fool’s Day is all about jokes and pranks, but when it comes to retirement planning, getting fooled can cost you real money. Today, we’re uncovering the beliefs that can fool retirees and pre-retirees into making bad financial moves. We’ll cover some of the most common myths that can damage your retirement plans and explain why they might not make much sense for you.
March 24, 2025
Using a Tax Refund to Fund an IRA
March 24, 2025
Top 10 IRA Rollover Mistakes
Show More